Paper Mario Nintendo 64 · 2000
version
$320
CIB — complete in box
sold $297–$330 · highest recorded sale $476
● high confidence · 18 sales
$165
Loosecart
$320
CIBcomplete
$400+
Sealeda.k.a. "new"
$61+
Gradedby grade ↓
◀ common · cheaperrarer · pricier ▶
drag the handle or tap a condition · every state priced & confidence-rated
◆ Graded? the premium is mostly trust — and it swings hugely by grade & whether sealed — see the full breakdown →
🔎 See 12 CIB on eBay 🇺🇸→
↳ auto-set to your region · change anytime
On eBay right now — CIB
12 live · eBay.com · refreshed just nowsells for $320
$185
quick sale · auction
$1,187
mint · highest recorded sale
Asks run higher than final sales. The green mark is what a CIB copy actually sells for — click any listing to verify and buy on your own eBay.
Buying or selling this one?
Post an intent at an honest price and we match you to the other side — better than a raw eBay search. Or ask your AI agent: it reads this page and can post the intent for you.
◇ agent-ready: /game/n64/paper-mario.md · /mcp
◈ open intents: 0 open →
machine-readable · built on intents.md
Graded — WATA / CGC
priced by grade, not one numberCGC 7.5$61graded
WATA 8.5C$150graded
CGC 64$247graded
CGC 9.6$259graded
WATA 9.0$342graded
CGC 8.5$378graded
WATA 8.5$383graded
CGC 8.0$390graded
VGA 9$475graded
CGC 8.5C$599graded
WATA 9.8$640sealed
CGC 9.4$680graded
CGC 9.0$699sealed
WATA 9.0C$699graded
WATA 9.0$725sealed
CGC 9.0$780graded
WATA 8.5A$820sealed
CGC 6$900sealed
VGA 90$900graded
VGA 80$958sealed
CGC 9.4A$975sealed
PSA 8$999graded
CGC 8.0A$1,000sealed
CGC 8.5$1,000sealed
CGC 9.4$1,025sealed
PSA 9$1,040sealed
PSA 9.0$1,100sealed
WATA 9.4$1,125sealed
WATA 8.0$1,175graded
WATA 9.4$1,179graded
PSA 9.0A$1,200sealed
VGA 8$1,200graded
WATA 9.4A$1,211graded
WATA 9.0A$1,258sealed
WATA 9.2A$1,616sealed
VGA 9$2,000sealed
WATA 9.4A$2,100sealed
CGC 9.6$2,125sealed
VGA 8$2,327sealed
PSA 9.2A$2,500sealed
Why graded isn't a single number: a graded price depends on the grade and whether it's sealed — a top WATA sealed tops everything, a mid graded sits near CIB. We split it, WATA and CGC priced separately, and never claim to authenticate a seal.
What is Paper Mario (Nintendo 64) worth?
Paper Mario on Nintendo 64 is estimated here by condition and region from sold-price data, each rated for confidence. Loose carts, complete-in-box (CIB), sealed and graded copies each sell for very different amounts, and PAL and NTSC are separate markets we never average together.
Is a loose Paper Mario cart worth anything?
See the "Loose" figure above — it's the most common condition and usually the cheapest; region and condition matter more than rarity.
Why is the sealed price a "best guess" sometimes?
When only a few genuine sealed sales exist — and many "sealed" copies are resealed — we show a clearly rated best-guess rather than a fake-precise number.